Johnny - You shouldn't be her best friend. You can still be her friend but don't let her think she can have her cake and eat it too. I think she's right that if things don't work out, that your friendship will never be the same. That being said, if you think you guys would be that great together, then you should tell her that you really think you need to try it out. If she says no at that point, she should realize she's jeapordizing the friendship.

i disagree with the other guy..
some people, after being best friends that date, they are just the same as they were before they dated...
although it doesnt work out for everyone it doesnt hurt to try..
its really up to you guys if you break up and wanna still be friends..

Your a faggot.